We've mentioned this here before, but Jenna Marshall is one of the more manipulative people on a show full of manipulative people. The first girl Emily ever dated, Maya St.
They had a secret relationship, hidden from the other students and townspeople. Yeah, it was not great. The pair have been spotted out and about in early Marlene King's series that followed a group of high school girls as they were threatened by a series of anonymous individuals, is no exception here. Played by Tammin Sursok, Jenna radiated an aggressively selfish, vindictive energy that most normal characters on the show just tried to avoid. They broke up shortly after confirming their relationship because work was too much of a priority for her. Tyler also keeps his relationships on the DL, but one we do know about is his fling with Lauren Hoover.